Rick,
This is not totally on my topic but you stated in your "close":

"Subjective, perhaps but the subjective opinion of acknowledged educated photographers will get us much closer to the stated goal of the contest."

OK: I used to be quite proficient at photography. Nikon F's, Hasselblads, the whole shootin' match. I still take "OK" photos but nothing I would entertain as an entry in Edo's contest. I would not enter at any rate, as I feel it "may" give the impression of self-absorption.
I post photos on these forums to show folks various Randall knives, hunting, fishing, etc. "stuff". Some have found them educational, fun, at the very least...Somethin' to look at. I have never considered them "good enough" to enter Edo's contest...let alone "win"!!
My point is: If the contest is to encourage more "quality" photos and get more good, great, perhaps interesting quality photos why don't "we" help folks like...well..."ME"!! Why can't we couple this new photo contest with a "digital photography for dummies" (myself included) self-help photo thread.
Just as an example: Say the "winning" or "second" place photo is stunning and folks would like to know the "how" to try and accomplish a finished product similar to it. Why can't we establish a "semi-monthly" thread...or a "pinned" thread, similar to the Randall ordering thread, where folks can go and get some form of tutorial as to "F-stop" settings, blade angle, photo-shop tricks of the trade. "ISO" settings and other various "helpful hints" to get more members (and non members) in the game?
Personally: I love looking at Jim Gates' photos as well as Ken's..."BUT...(You knew that word was coming sometime) I would also like to challenge myself to try and create an image like those. I think the "new" photo contest could be linked to an opportunity to help and further "include" all of us...Just sayin'...What do the rest of ya' think.
Best, Capt. Chris
PS: Now...I really gotta finish packin' and get "on the road" to Savannah...Great weekend to all...CCS