Tom,

Unfortunately, there is not much of a debate, because the EDO Photo Contest is all about "Excellence In Knife Photography," and to some that means something. In fact, that exact quoted phrase is included in its logo. We should respect that. In fact, for the judges, it is prudent that they respect that phrase. To do anything different means taking steps back, not forward.

Excellence in anything should be rewarded. To reward mediocrity goes against the spirit of this contest. Yes, it may sound harsh to some, but that is how we grow as people. If I take a crappy photo (and I do take some crappy photos), I want to get an honest critique, not some "feel good" or false judgment. In other words, I want an honest assessment, which is the only way in which I can figure out how to do better next time.

To conclude, I prefer not to derail the new rules and judging criteria that Edo has set forth, so before you become too critical of them, I strongly suggest that you (and others) give them a chance, and have a bit of faith. I take the role of judging quite seriously, and I am confident that the other judges, which include Edo himself, feel the same.