Originally Posted By: Dirty_Water
Joe,

I'll be polite with this reply as I possibly can, I think the lack of comments on your massacre...errr...customization of a model 28 looks like crap to me, and totally unnecessary as shown in comparison to the model 26. Absolutely no lines, and you don't appear to be choking up any further than a choil would keep you from anyways...You could have ordered a 26 with a BPH and achieved the end results. But hey, it's now your knife, u paid for the right to do with it whatever you seem necessary to achieve the desired result...so, choose away...IMO

You are a jeweler by trade correct? I have a deal with my jeweler here in Orlando after trying to polish my wedding ring here at the shop and almost losing a diamond...he doesn't work on his Randalls and I no longer buff my jewelery....

---DW---


Thanks for being gentle,....but your opinion doesn't phase me. I wouldn't have started this thread if I didn't expect to have opinions that were not supportive.

Possibly any lack of comments or others sharing their own customizations just "might" be because of anticipating comments such as yours?

You're a Randall worker (Scott,...shop foreman right?),...and have been programmed into seeing the same angled grind shapes over and over! laugh

But really,...."no lines"? A full flat ground knife has "no lines" maybe in your eyes either, but it is probably the most used grind of all time. It WORKS very well, and not only in the kitchen! Yet I don't believe Randall has ever offered one??? Strange........

False upper edges and angled grind lines are used on a lot Randall knifes, but truthfully don't serve ANY useful purpose as far as overall cutting ability is concerned. Those are more design elements in my view,.....makes a prettier knife maybe,....and are easier to put into a thicker knife blade stock than a thin one.

Getting blade stock thickness down DOES make a difference, which was one of my main objectives in proceeding as i did. Not every knife has to be built like a crowbar, or have a large finger choil in a most useful part of the blade with best leverage! laugh

Sportsman knives should be offered in 1/8" stock more often,....it's PLENTY thick and durable for that use,....and can be ground to cut much better overall in other applications. Isn't that what a knife is made for? (unless you're just a collector of pretty grind lines?)

BTW, I retired form jewelery work after doing it for 35 years,....it gets old after awhile. (But I STILL get folks wanting me to do their work, as there ARE too many bad jewelers out there)


Edited by Joe Tousignant (04/08/15 02:44 PM)