Fakes

Posted by: Mindelsee

Fakes - 06/12/22 08:53 PM

I was scanning the internet tonight and ran across what I believe to be a fake. I am showing it here. Thoughts?

https://www.ebay.com/itm/294985518049?hash=item44ae81cbe1:g:TLIAAOSwey5igOxv

Posted by: Mindelsee

Re: Fakes - 06/12/22 08:57 PM

Additional info from the eBay post-

Randall Made Knives
Model - 15, kit knife blade and sheath
Condition - unused
Made - 70's
Blade - 5 1/2" carbon steel, ricasso is stamped made in Germany
Overall length - 10 3/8"
Sheath - Johnson rough back model "C"
No stone
Posted by: rodbrown

Re: Fakes - 06/12/22 09:04 PM

I have dealt with the seller many times and will vouch for him. One of the Model 5’s that I got at Blade (picture posted on this Forum) came from him.
Posted by: Mindelsee

Re: Fakes - 06/12/22 09:16 PM

With no disrespect directed to the seller, is this a fake?
Posted by: Michael_Mason

Re: Fakes - 06/12/22 09:19 PM

Steve is as good as they get. If he’s got it listed, it’s good to go. Buy with confidence..
PM sent !!
Posted by: Mindelsee

Re: Fakes - 06/12/22 09:41 PM

I have not seen any documentation to indicate Randall blades marked made in Germany....
Posted by: rodbrown

Re: Fakes - 06/12/22 09:55 PM

RMK used Soligen (Germany) blades for many years, mid 50’s to mid 70’s? Not absolutely sure of the years.
Posted by: Captain Chris Stanaback

Re: Fakes - 06/13/22 12:38 AM

It's real. Solingen blades were contracted by RMK in the 1960's and used throughout the VietNam war...and beyond.
Capt. Chris
Posted by: Michael_Mason

Re: Fakes - 06/13/22 08:26 AM

Originally Posted By: Mindelsee
I have not seen any documentation to indicate Randall blades marked made in Germany....

Maybe you should invest in buying the book "Randall Made Knives", written by Robert L. Gaddis, and reading it??