A ding on the edge

Posted by: Yonder

A ding on the edge - 07/14/18 02:59 PM

Let’s say hypothetically a person has a model 12-14 grind and when they were skinning branches to make a Walkingstick the Walkingstick got the better of the edge and put a ding in it, what options does that person have?
Posted by: Byrdguy

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/14/18 03:36 PM

Send it to the shop and they'll make it like new.
Posted by: CrazyCajun

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/14/18 03:56 PM

Looks like you may be right down the street with the Orlando location!!! Take a ride!!!
Posted by: RamKingJC

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/14/18 09:06 PM

Batoning is typically not covered within the realm of the Randall warranty. ..
Posted by: W Polidori

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/14/18 10:02 PM

Read the OP and doesn't sound like he was battoning as in splitting anything. Chopping maybe. Right tool for the job, no idea? Send it back to the shop, they will respond.
Posted by: Dirty_Water

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/14/18 11:43 PM

Yeah, just bring on by, we'll take a look at it... May just need a "Ben-edge"...;)
Posted by: Steel6

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/16/18 04:10 PM

Originally Posted By: Dirty_Water
Yeah, just bring on by, we'll take a look at it... May just need a "Ben-edge"...;)


That’s funny.

New shop code? BE
Posted by: Leatherman

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/16/18 05:47 PM

I've not actually damaged the edge before. My 1-6 had a dent/misalignment in the lower portion of the bevel. The actual cutting edge was undamaged.

I'm very happy with this 2018 5-6 and the heavy bevel is a great addition or at least how this knife was ground.
Posted by: Yonder

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/16/18 08:52 PM

Thanks all. Scott told me not to chop with it. I thought I was on the shy side of it. 😕
Posted by: W Polidori

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 08:22 AM

So you back in business Rod?
Posted by: Eric

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 09:04 AM

I have a rehandled #14 Solingen Kit Blade that has chopped everything from Red Oak limbs to Cottonwood Trees to feed my Mulcher/chipper for the last 2 summers and it still looks the same edgewise as when James Behring shipped it back to me 2 years ago. The handle shape is perfect for chopping. Zero rollovers.

No warranty implied. The #14 chops and dices any wood I have growing here.

Posted by: Leatherman

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 09:27 AM

I like that handle, like a BPH almost. Goes great with the vintage blade!

I have also chopped plenty of oak and hickory etc with models 5,16sf,14,15 and a #1.

Posted by: Eric

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 10:05 AM

Ben, I like the RMK finger grips too.

A couple of wipes with the steel rod and a dash of soapy water and voila.
Posted by: Leatherman

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 10:19 AM

Holy cow! Pun intended haha
Posted by: BladesNBarrels

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 10:44 AM

Beautiful steaks.
You have a steady hand getting the same thickness.
Impressive.
Posted by: Eric

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 10:49 AM

Thanks, David, the right tool for the job makes things easier.

P.S.
Sorry for hijacking another thread. I seem to be DB Cooper on this forum.
Posted by: BladesNBarrels

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 06:12 PM

Originally Posted By: Eric

Sorry for hijacking another thread. I seem to be DB Cooper on this forum.


That's how you picked up all those great knives?
smile
Posted by: Eric

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 07:02 PM

David, I never met an RMK I didn't like. Some Impact me more than others, but they are all highly favored.
Posted by: pappy19

Re: A ding on the edge - 07/17/18 08:42 PM

Amen Bro Eric.

Pap
Posted by: Yonder

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/09/18 11:34 AM

Thanks Scott. Looks great.
Posted by: crsides

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/10/18 11:48 AM

I had no idea you could actually use a Randall to cut something.

Charlie

Posted by: desert.snake

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/12/18 11:54 AM

Today returned from a small hike, #10-5 perfectly worked,
I made some canopies for products and things,
made small splinters for bonfire as Leatherman.
10-5 easily cuts fresh wood, for dry wood it has
a little lack of weight (YMMV).

I did not take an ax, my friend had to take him,
but he forgot it. Then it turned out that we forgot
the arc-frame for the tent))
The frame was made with a knife. In my opinion,
the knife will not full replace the ax in power work,
but if there is no choice, then he must do it.

Any use of the good tool is cool, it does not matter
whether you cut down a forest or show it in a showcase
Posted by: Leatherman

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/12/18 07:39 PM

I've not owned a model 10 but it does look like a handy knife. Not sure I would baton or at least baton anything over two inches with it.

When something breaks or you forget it, creativity or bust!
Posted by: pappy19

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/13/18 12:02 AM

A 5" Model 19 does it all, small hatchet on one side and regular knife on the other.

Pap
Posted by: Chief

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/13/18 07:57 PM

The adult fireman
Posted by: desert.snake

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/21/18 08:14 AM









Posted by: Yonder

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/25/18 05:32 PM

I’ll start this with to each his own in their knife utilization.
Just a final word about my OP. If I were to “baton” anything it would be with a froe. In a life or death situation, sure, I’ll use what is at hand. But in a planned hike, hunt, adventure, I’ll (hopefully) have the right tool for the right job. I mean, a Randall Made Knife is akin to the 45 ACP; it can do it all. Just hold it near the skinning pole and the deer hide falls off, but I realize that something else may be in order when I want to take down a redwood, although it would fall like downed by Paul Bunyan if one chose to use their RMK. Sometimes one doesn’t want the noise of a chainsaw.
The preceding was written with a wink and a nod.
If anyone cares to read about real world Randall knife use. Find the article in the museum about the Solomon Islands. That was life or death.

Best to all.
Posted by: Holzinger258

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/26/18 07:10 PM

Originally Posted By: Yonder
If I were to “baton” anything it would be with a froe.

I got just the thing for ya!
Posted by: Yonder

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/27/18 11:49 AM

Neat
Posted by: Leatherman

Re: A ding on the edge - 08/27/18 02:47 PM

The only reason the handle is vertical is because it would break if it was straight like a knife. I've only ever broke one knife in half batoning wood and that was because it was serrated, a kabar kn d2 steel.

My dad told me about a froe years ago but we could never find one around the farm or in stores. I'd like to give one a try "but" I feel it would be worse than a knife. A model #5 and many others are 1/4 or thicker (i think my heavy bevel knife is slightly thicker) almost to the tip. I feel batoning and shear cutting (using s baton to shear through smaller limbs or whatever is possibly the best aspect of the design.